TROUBLING TREND: Business for America survey shows companies face more political backlash for social advocacy
TROUBLING TREND: Business for America survey shows companies face more political backlash for social advocacy
By Marilyn Odendahl
The Indiana Citizen
November 24, 2023
Along with taking care of customers and tending to the bottom line, businesses increasingly are expecting to be attacked over culture war issues, according to a new survey recently released by Business for America.
Companies that are swept into a political backlash can suffer severe consequences, the survey said. They can be targeted for consumer boycotts of their products, they can face a public relations crisis and they could be subjected to special laws and regulations enacted solely as punishment by politicians who want to score points with their political bases.
“The takeaway here is that backlash is growing,†Sarah Bonk, founder and CEO of Business for America, said. “And it’s becoming more precarious for companies to take action on a variety of social and political issues that they and their stakeholders care about.â€
Business for America, a nonpartisan, nonprofit organization focused on improving civic participation and voter turnout, surveyed more than 50 business leaders from around the country to learn what it could do to help civic-minded companies navigate the current political environment. The business leaders were asked their views of the culture wars, how the risk of a backlash was affecting their social impact work and what resources they needed to navigate these issues.
In a recent webinar, Business for America released its findings in its report, “Business Perspectives on Political Backlash.â€
Bonk emphasized the results could not be applied across the entire business sector, because the survey was not scientifically randomized and presented just a sample of the Business for America network. Still, she said the findings – gleaned from responses from leaders of Fortune 500 companies to small-business owners – had merit because they were a “very helpful indicator of business concerns.â€
The survey found a growing concern about getting caught in a political backlash sparked by taking action on social issues. A whopping 89% of the respondents agreed that attacks on business from political figures are at an all-time high, while 93% agreed the attacks are driven by political agendas and not by a genuine desire to solve problems.
“At the root of the issue is America’s dysfunctional hyper-partisan politics,†Bonk said.
Underscoring how sensitive business leaders are about political backlash, Bonk said several of the respondents asked to have the survey invitation sent to their personal email addresses rather than their company email.
‘Sign of democratic decline’
Protect Democracy, a nonpartisan, nonprofit dedicated to strengthening American democracy, sees the survey results as indicating a wider assault on the country’s founding principles.
Speaking as part of the webinar, Corey Dukes, policy advocate at Protect Democracy, highlighted a change in the political climate within the past 10 years. He pointed out businesses and their leaders have long taken stances on public policies or social issues – and political leaders disagreeing and criticizing those stances has been normal as well.
“However, we are seeing with increasing frequency something different and more troubling to folks like us at Protect Democracy. We’re seeing officials at all levels of government using powers of the state to target private companies for either real or perceived expressions of viewpoints,†Dukes said, adding the tactic has accelerated greatly since the Trump administration. “Importantly, what we’ve seen in the last few years, too, is that no company is too big or too small to avoid being in the crosshairs.â€
Both Democrats and Republicans have threatened action against private businesses. Examples include Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis, a Republican, installing his own appointees to the district board which oversees municipal services at Disney World in Orlando, after Disney officials criticized the state’s “Don’t Say Gay†law. California Gov. Gavin Newsome, a Democrat, briefly refused to renew the state’s contract with Walgreens, when the retailer stopped selling the abortion pill mifepristone.
Indiana Attorney General Todd Rokita has been on the forefront of some of the culture war battles with big business.
In May, Rokita co-led 17 Republican attorneys general in a fight over ESG (environment, social and governance) policies by asking the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission to review BlackRock’s holdings in utility companies. He accused the investment firm of embracing what he called “radical leftist ideologies,†after BlackRock signed on to the environmental initiatives of Climate Action 100+ and Net Zero Asset Managers.
Rokita followed that by joining 12 other attorneys general in July and sending a letter to Fortune 100 CEOs threatening that their companies would be “held accountable – sooner rather than later†if they continued to pursue DEI (diversity, equity and inclusion) goals in hiring and contracting. The letter cited the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2023 decision in Students for Fair Admissions v. President & Fellows of Harvard College, which struck down affirmative action in college admissions and said the prohibition extended to other aspects of life, such as employment.
Aisha Woodward, policy advocate at Protect Democracy, said government actors retaliating against private businesses is a problem that impacts the entire country.
“Using government power to target and retaliate against businesses for expressed viewpoints is a known sign of democratic decline,†Woodward said. “These kinds of attacks can create a permission structure for other political leaders to copy that behavior and can result in a chilling effect on free speech and expression.â€
Scoring political points
Business leaders told Business for America the issues they see as making their companies most vulnerable to government attack are DEI hiring and training practices, ESG investing, and LGBTQ+ issues.
The survey found many companies are adjusting their approach to social impact work, although none of the respondents said they had made “significant reductions†in that work. A majority of the respondents, 68%, said they had not changed their social impact activities, while 19% said they were increasing their social impact work and 13% said they were decreasing the work.
Richard Eidlin, national policy director at Business for America, believes politicians who attack companies have lost sight of the importance of a thriving business sector.
“I think that certain elected officials have somehow reversed in their mind the impact of an attack on business as an employer and the benefits that that company brings to a given community from their much narrower political agenda,†Eidlin said. “Their political agenda is the most important thing on their mind and if there can be a political point scored with a cross section of the public, that takes precedent.â€
Looking ahead to 2024 and the heightened divisiveness brought by the presidential election, Business for America is launching a new initiative especially to help businesses prepare for political backlash. Once a month, the organization will host a private forum where business leaders can gather to review case studies, exchange best practices, share messaging and discuss policy.
Bonk certainly does not foresee the backlash abating.
She linked the volatile political atmosphere to news stories “optimized for clicks,†social media fueling outrage, election systems that drive divisiveness through closed primaries and gerrymandering, and partisan politics that reward extremism. In the “absence of leadership from our elected leaders,†Bonk said, companies are under growing pressure from grassroots organizations, shareholder activists and investors to either take action or stop taking action, depending on the circumstance or issue.
“Today’s toxic, hyper-partisan political climate is pouring sugar into America’s economic engine,†Bonk said in a press release. “Our country remains in a post-pandemic economic downturn, and we cannot afford to have politicians hamstring business by weaponizing every social issue and attempting to restrict free speech.â€
FOOTNOTE: Dwight Adams, a freelance editor and writer based in Indianapolis, edited this article. He is a former content editor, copy editor and digital producer at The Indianapolis Star and IndyStar.com, and worked as a planner for other newspaper
Small Business Saturday is November 25
Small Business Saturday is November 25
Support Small Businesses in Downtown Evansville
ANNOUNCEMENT – November 25, 2023: The Downtown Evansville Economic Improvement District (EID) celebrates the 13th Annual Small Business Saturday® on Saturday, November 25 from 9 AM – 4 PM in Downtown Evansville.
“All year long we emphasize the importance of shopping small, but the biggest shopping day of the year for our shops is Small Business Saturday,†said Adam Trinkel, EID executive director. Shopping small supports real economic growth in our community through jobs, business ownership opportunities, tax base, and on average two-thirds of every dollar ($0.67) spent at a small business in the U.S. stays in that local community.1
The EID will distribute maps, buttons, and limited-quantity custom Shop Downtown bags, courtesy of Heritage Federal Credit Union, at 318 Main Street beginning at 9 AM. The EID will be selling Downtown Evansville branded attire as well. Individual stores will feature specials throughout the day, and unique specialty vendors with items ranging from clothing to baked goods will be located along Main Street from 2nd to 6th Streets. Shoppers will also enjoy live music from local musicians. Brick-and-mortar merchants will also have a limited supply of free tote bags for shoppers, courtesy of American Express.
New for 2023, shoppers have an added incentive with a new Shop Small Passport. When shoppers make a purchase at any of the 10 participating locations, they will receive a stamp on their passport from that business. Each stamp is one entry to win a gift card to a Downtown business. The more stamps a shopper receives on their passport, the more entries they will have to win gift cards. Passports will be distributed at each individual business and should be returned to the EID tent at 318 Main Street by 3 PM on Saturday.
Screaming Eagles conclude Challenge with #9 Duke
USI comes home Tuesday for 3-game homestand
DURHAM, N.C. – University of Southern Indiana Men’s Basketball concludes its three-game road swing in the Duke Blue Devil Challenge when it visits ninth-ranked Duke University Friday at Cameron Indoor Stadium in Durham, North Carolina. The game will air on the ACC Network at 5 p.m. (CST).
Â
Fan also can follow all of the action on the ESPN+ app and can be heard on ESPN 97.7FM (http://listentotheref.com) and 95.7FM The Spin (http://957thespin.com).
Â
USI (1-5) is 0-2 in the first two games of the Challenge, losing a heartbreaker at La Salle University, 79-78, and a disappointing game at Bucknell University, 67-56. Sophomore guard AJ Smith (Edwardsville, Illinois) has led the Screaming Eagles on the road trip with 12.0 points and seven rebounds per contest.
Â
Junior guard Jeremiah Hernandez (Chicago, Illinois) and junior forward Jack Mielke (Downers Grove, Illinois) follow with 11.5 points per game, while junior guard Jordan Tillmon (Pine Bluff, Arkansas) rounds out the double-digit scorers with 11.0 points per game.
Â
For the season, Smith and Hernandez lead the Eagles with 12.3 points per game. Smith also has the team-lead in rebounds with 8.7 per outing.
Â
Duke enters Friday’s game on a three-game winning streak, defeating Bucknell, 90-60, and La Salle, 95-66, in the Challenge. The Blue Devils started their winning streak with a 74-65 win over fourth-ranked Michigan State University in the neutral site State Farm Champions Classic in Chicago, Illinois.
Â
Following Friday’s game, the Eagles return to the friendly surroundings of Screaming Eagles Arena next week to start a three-game homestand. USI begins the homestand Tuesday (November 28) by hosting East/West University at 7 p.m.
Â
The homestand will continue December 2 when USI hosts Bowling Green State University and concludes December 6 versus Purdue University Ft. Wayne. Tipoff versus Bowling Green is 3 p.m., while tipoff against Ft. Wayne is slated for 7 p.m.
EPD DAILY ACTIVITY REPORT
FOOTNOTE: Â EPD DAILY ACTIVITY REPORT information was provided by the EPD and posted by the City-County-County Observer without opinion, bias, or editing.
Hot Jobs
Front Desk / Admin. LSI Staffing  3.6  – Evansville, IN
$13 – $15 an hour Easily apply
Responsive employer
Greet and welcome guests in a friendly and professional manner. Check-in and check-out guests efficiently and accurately. Pay: $13.00 – $15.00 per hour. Just posted
Part-time Office Assistant Ace Construction  4  – Evansville, IN
$15 – $17 an hour Easily apply
Expected hours: 20 – 24 per week. Ace Roofing and Construction is looking for a part time office assistant to help with answering a multi line phone system and… Just posted
Front Desk Agent -$13 -Full Time-Doubletree of Evansville HCW MANAGEMENT CONSULTANTS LLCÂ Â 3.8Â Â – Evansville, IN
$13 an hour Easily apply
Answer guest inquires about hotel service, facilities and hours of operation. Front Desk Agents are responsible for greeting and registering the guest,… Just posted
Administrative Assistant – Posey County EMA Posey County EMAÂ – Mount Vernon, IN $41,000 a year Easily apply
Practical knowledge of and ability to make practical application of budget and grant preparation and administration. Performs related duties as assigned. Just posted