|
|
|
|
Attorney General Curtis Hill has joined a bipartisan coalition of 47 other attorneys general in suing Facebook, alleging the social networking giant illegally stifles competition to protect its monopoly power.
The attorneys general allege in a civil complaint that, over the last decade, Facebook illegally acquired competitors in a predatory manner and cut services to smaller threats, depriving users from the benefits of competition and reducing privacy protections and services along the way — all in an effort to boost its bottom line through increased advertising revenue.
Facebook is specifically charged with violating Section 2 of the Sherman Act, in addition to multiple violations of Section 7 of the Clayton Act. In October, Attorney General Hill joined a separate but similar lawsuit against Google, alleging the company has a stranglehold on the United States search market.
“For years now, Facebook has used anticompetitive business tactics to rise from young upstart to unlawful monopoly. Tech giants like Facebook cannot build moats around their businesses to retain their dominance,†Attorney General Hill said. “It’s time that the courts recognize the harm Facebook’s business practices have caused and put a stop to them.â€
Since 2004, Facebook has operated as a personal social networking service that facilitates sharing content online without charging users a monetary fee. Instead, Facebook provides these services in exchange for a user’s time, attention, and personal data. Facebook then monetizes its business by selling advertising to firms that attach immense value to the user engagement and highly targeted advertising that Facebook can deliver due to the vast trove of data it collects on users, their friends, and their interests.
Facebook’s unlawful monopoly gives it broad discretion to set the terms for how its users’ private information is collected and used to further its business interests. When Facebook cuts off integration to third-party developers, users cannot easily move their own information — such as their lists of friends — to other social networking services. This decision forces users to either stay put or start their online lives from scratch if they want to try an alternative.
Because Facebook users have nowhere else to go, the company is able to make decisions about how to curate content on the platform and use the personal information it collects from users to further its business interests, even if those choices conflict with the interests and preferences of Facebook users.
The harm to consumers over the last decade comes as a direct result of Facebook’s acquisition of smaller firms that pose competitive threats. Facebook employs unique data-gathering tools to monitor new apps to see what is gaining traction with users. That data helps Facebook select acquisition targets that pose the greatest threats to Facebook’s dominance. Once selected, Zuckerberg and Facebook offer the heads of these companies vast amounts of money — that greatly inflate the values of the apps — all in hopes of avoiding any competition for Facebook in the future.
Facebook and Zuckerberg saw Instagram as a direct threat quickly after the company launched. After initially trying to build its own version of Instagram that gained no traction, Zuckerberg admitted in early 2012 that Facebook was “very behind†Instagram and a better strategy would be “to consider paying a lot of money†for the photo-sharing app in an effort to “neutralize a potential competitor.â€
In April 2012, Facebook acquired Instagram for $1 billion. Facebook also acquired WhatsApp in 2014 for nearly $19 billion.
The attorneys general argue that Facebook targets competitors with a “buy or bury” approach: if they refuse to be bought out, Facebook tries to squeeze every bit of oxygen out of the room for these companies. To facilitate this goal, Facebook has used an “open first–closed later†strategy to stop competitive threats, or deter them from competing, at the inception.
Facebook’s response to competitors also serves as a warning to other apps that if they encroach on Facebook’s territory, Facebook will end their access to crucial integrations. Facebook’s actions also deter venture capitalists from investing in companies that Facebook might in the future see as competitors.
In their complaint, led by New York Attorney General Letitia James, the attorneys general asked the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia to halt Facebook’s illegal, anticompetitive conduct and block the company from continuing this behavior in the future. Additionally, the attorneys general asked the court to restrain Facebook from making further acquisitions valued at or more than $10 million without advance notice to the state of New York and other plaintiff states. Finally, the court was asked to provide any additional relief it determines is appropriate, including the divestiture or restructuring of illegally acquired companies, or current Facebook assets or business lines.
A new and exciting addition to the up-and-coming culinary landscape of Evansville, Old National Events Plaza will host the third installment of its Dinner on the Bridge series on Saturday, December 12, 2020.
Located in one of the most unique settings in the city, Dinner on the Bridge takes place on the sky bridge above Martin Luther King Jr. Boulevard which connects Old National Events Plaza to the DoubleTree Hotel and Ford Center. Reservations are limited to 20 guests to ensure diners receive an exclusive experience, and world-class service while parties remain socially distant. Attention is paid to every detail throughout the evening, with safety being the top priority.
Dinner on the Bridge offers five courses of fine cuisine curated by George Sidaros, Old National Events Plaza’s Director of Food & Beverage. Delizia! An Italian Holiday features a wide-ranging menu of carefully prepared dishes, from Crab Cake Arancini to Roasted Herbed Lamb Chop, finished in front of diners by Chef Sidaros. Wine pairings are offered throughout the evening to enhance each course, with tasting notes provided by a sommelier. The experience is intimate, as Chef and Sommelier guide guests through the menu, and attendees receive recipes from the evening to take home.
“We want to show Evansville and the region how convention center dining can be more fun, elegant and diverse. We thought the best way to start a new experience was to take guests out of the banquet rooms and use a unique space within our venue,†notes Chef Sidaros.
Sophisticated enough for the experienced foodie, while remaining accessible to those just starting to expand their palate, Dinner on the Bridge creates an atmosphere unlike any other in Evansville, where fine dining meets entertainment.
What:Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Dinner on the Bridge, Delizia! An Italian Holiday
When:Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Saturday, December 12, 2020, 6 PM
Where:Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Old National Events Plaza
Tickets:               $95.00 per person, includes five courses, a welcome cocktail, three wine pairings, coffee, and petit four.
For the complete menu and additional information, visit oldnationaeventsplaza.com
SOUTHERN INDIANA HOUSE DEMOCRATS RECEIVE COMMITTEE ASSIGNMENTS
INDIANAPOLIS – Here are the Indiana House committee assignments for Democrats representing Southern Indiana:
State Rep. Ryan Hatfield (D-Evansville) will be ranking Democrat on both the Judiciary Committee and Employment, Labor and Pensions Committee. He will also be serving on two other committees: Public Health; and Utilities, Energy, and Telecommunications.
State Rep. Rita Fleming (D-Jeffersonville) will be ranking Democrat on the Commerce, Small Business and Economic Development Committee and serves on two other committees: Natural Resources; and Public Health.
By LaMonte Richardson Jr
TheStatehouseFile.com
INDIANAPOLIS— Daily Hoosier COVID-19 cases dipped to fewer than 5,500 for the first time in December, making Tuesday the lowest daily number of positive cases reported in Indiana since Nov. 28.
But as the number of cases appears to decline slightly, deaths and hospitalizations continue to mount from the highly contagious novel coronavirus. The Indiana Department of Health announced Tuesday that 5,457 additional Hoosiers were diagnosed with COVID-19, bringing the number of Indiana residents now known to have had COVID-19 to 392,663.
In addition, another 124 Hoosiers are confirmed to have died from COVID-19, for a total of 6,109 people known to have succumbed to the disease. Another 301 probable deaths have been reported based on diagnoses in patients for whom no positive test is on record. Deaths are reported based on when data are received by the state and occurred over multiple days.
Out of all tests administered, 14% are positive, and out of all the unique tests, 27.6% are positive or more than one in four.
To date, 2,338,308 unique individuals have been tested in Indiana, up from 2,323,969 on Monday. A total of 4,656,827 tests, including repeat tests for unique individuals, have been reported to the health department since Feb. 26.
Data on the health department dashboard show that about one in three positive cases are in the children and adult through age 29 group. But even though young people are testing positive at higher rates than the rest of the population, three in four deaths occur in people over age 70.
There are 3,250 people hospitalized with COVID-19 on Monday. The health also reported that 43.8% of Indiana’s ICU beds are currently being occupied by COVID-19 patients, with 20.9% of beds being available. Of all the ventilators available in the state, 14.2% are being used by COVID-19 patients.
FOOTNOTE: LaMonte Richardson Jr. is a reporter with TheStatehouseFile.com, a news website powered by Franklin College journalism students.
The University of Evansville (UE) will host a celebration for Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. on January 18, 2021. The annual event will be held in a virtual format this year to accommodate COVID-19 guidelines. Each activity will be available online, and the event is free and open to the public. To attend, please visit evansville.edu/cdei for the event’s Zoom links. The 2021 theme is “Our Time is Now” and highlights one of King’s famous quotes, “The time is always right to do what is right.”
The schedule of events is available below.
Symbolic March – January 1-18, 2021
To commemorate the 54-mile Civil Rights March of 1965, UE will hold a virtual symbolic march. Between the dates of January 1-18, participants can log miles online through walking, running, biking, or swimming. At 11:00 a.m. on the day of the celebration, UE encourages participants to complete the 54th mile together.
While there is no registration fee, individuals can make donations toward positive social change at uealumnionline.com/MLKDay2021. All proceeds will go directly towards UE’s Zerah Priestly Carter Scholarship and the Center for Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion.
Virtual Celebration – 11:45 a.m.
The celebration will culminate with the 54-mile march and kick-off the rest of the activities for the day. Speakers will include Christopher M. Pietruszkiewicz, president of UE; Rob Shelby, PhD, chief diversity officer; members of the Black Student Union; and lectureship keynote speaker Karith Foster.
Local Leaders Panel Discussion – 2:00 p.m.
The discussion will include leaders from the Evansville community. The panel will be led by Melissa Moore, a UE alumna and secretary for the Legal Aid Society Board of Vanderburgh County.
Lectureship – 7:00 p.m.
Each year, the Martin Luther King, Jr. Lectureship is made possible by the generous support of William G. and Rose M. Mays.
The 2021 lectureship will feature keynote speaker Karith Foster. For nearly two decades, the speaker, humorist, and author has created a seismic shift in mindsets by addressing issues of free expression, diversity, and inclusion. Foster is known as the visionary behind “Inversity”, a philosophy and methodology intentionally designed to revolutionize and transform the way society addresses issues of diversity and leadership. A nationally renowned public speaker, Foster has presented at the United Nations and to executives of the Chamber of Commerce C100, as well as Harvard, Stanford and other organizations.
“Today’s action ensures that EPA is consistent in evaluating costs and benefits when developing broad-reaching policies that affect the American public,â€Â said EPA Administrator Andrew Wheeler. “Thanks to President Trump’s leadership, we are ensuring that future rulemakings under the Clean Air Act are transparent, fair, and consistent with EPA governing statutes, the American public deserves to know the benefits and costs of federal regulations.â€
This procedural rule will provide clarity for states, local communities, industry, and other stakeholders regarding EPA’s rulemaking considerations.
As a part of a larger effort of regulatory reform under the Trump Administration, EPA has taken a close look at how to improve assessments of benefits and costs that accompany regulatory actions. Many EPA statutes, including the Clean Air Act, contain language regarding cost consideration, but there are no regulations that ensure that EPA conducts an analysis of the benefits and costs in a consistent manner. This rule provides more consistent and transparent procedures to provide benefit cost analyses for significant rules promulgated under Clean Air Act.