Home Blog Page 5905

Governor Pence Hails Halt to Federal Overreach in Waters of the United States Regulation

4

The 6th Circuit Court of Appeals issued an Order of Stay preventing the implementation of the Waters of the United States regulation pending final judicial review.

 

In response, Governor Mike Pence issued the following statement:

 

“I am encouraged by the 6th Circuit’s decision to halt this federal overreach.  There are significant issues with this rule that must be carefully addressed.  The court’s Order of Stay ensures that Indiana will not be irreparably harmed by a rule that I believe will ultimately fail on its merits.

 

“The solutions to the challenges we face will most effectively emanate from our state capitals, not federal bureaucrats in Washington, D.C.  In Indiana, we are growing our economy, creating jobs, and feeding the world by eliminating bureaucratic red tape and reducing the size of government.  I believe that Hoosiers know best how to protect our waters, and this rule inhibits Indiana’s ability to manage its own affairs.”

 

Background: The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers issued the Waters of United States regulation in an attempt to clarify and redefine the limits of federal jurisdiction over waterways under the Clean Water Act.  In its Order, the 6th Circuit noted that, “the sheer breadth of the ripple effects caused by the Rule’s definitional changes counsels strongly in favor of maintaining the status quo for the time being.” In November of 2014, Governor Pence and Lt. Governor Sue Ellspermann sent letters to the EPA and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers urging them to withdraw the proposed rule that redefines “Waters of the United States” protected under the Clean Water Act. The letter in full can be found attached.

Governor Pence Letter to EPA 11.14.14

 

USDA Announces $3 Million in Funding for Critical Agriculture Production Research

0

The U.S. Department of Agriculture’s (USDA) National Institute of Food and Agriculture (NIFA) today announced nearly $3 million in grants to address critical issues affecting agriculturally-important plants and animals. The science developed from these grants will provide timely assistance and have an immediate impact for the agriculture community. The awards were made under the Agriculture and Food Research Initiative’s (AFRI) Critical Agricultural Research and Extension (CARE) program, and addresses priority areas of the 2014 Farm Bill.

“It is essential to promote partnerships between researchers, extension experts, and producers to ensure the success of American agriculture,” said Sonny Ramaswamy, NIFA director. “The CARE program is centered on the swift identification of problems, creation of solutions, and prevention of interruptions or issues that impact farmers’ ability to provide a safe and abundant food supply for our nation.”

Fiscal year 2014 is the first year NIFA has made awards under the CARE program. Examples of what these grants will focus on include a project from the University of Georgia that is researching disease management practices for blueberries, particularly addressing the currently unknown life cycle time of the damaging Exobasidium leaf and fruit spot disease. An Extension project from Montana State University will be working directly with cattle producers to adopt sagebrush grazing techniques for their cattle that create a sustainable environment for the greater sage-grouse. Fiscal Year 2014 grants include:

  • University of Florida, Gainesville, Fla., $149,399
  • University of Florida, Gainesville, Fla., $149,580
  • University of Georgia, Athens, Ga., $149,925
  • University of Hawaii, Honolulu, Hawaii, $149,884
  • Purdue University, West Lafayette, Ind., $149,995
  • Kansas State University, Manhattan, Kan., $149.988
  • Michigan State University, East Lansing, Mich., $149,655
  • Michigan State University, East Lansing, Mich., $149,899
  • Montana State University, Bozeman, Mont., $149,924
  • University of Nebraska-Lincoln, Lincoln, Neb., $148,203
  • University of Nebraska-Lincoln, Lincoln, Neb., $148,209
  • University of Nebraska-Lincoln, Lincoln, Neb., $150,000
  • Cornell University, Ithaca, N.Y., $150,000
  • North Carolina State University, Raleigh, N.C., $149,800
  • Pennsylvania State University, State College, Pa., $150,000
  • South Dakota State University, Brookings, S.D., $149,999
  • University of Tennessee-Knoxville, Knoxville, Tenn., $150,000
  • University of Vermont, Burlington, Vt., $141,807
  • Washington State University, Pullman, Wash., $149,837
  • University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, Wisc., $149,992

AFRI is NIFA’s flagship competitive grants program and was established under the 2008 Farm Bill. The AFRI Foundational Program addresses six priority areas to continue building a foundation of knowledge in fundamental and applied food and agricultural sciences critical for solving current and future societal challenges. The six priority areas include: plant health and production and plant products; animal health and production and animal products; food safety, nutrition and health; renewable energy, natural resources and environment; agriculture systems and technology; and agriculture economics and rural communities.

NIFA invests in and advances agricultural research, education, and extension and seeks to make transformative discoveries that solve societal challenges. To learn more about NIFA’s impact on agricultural science, visit nifa.usda.gov/impacts or follow us on Twitter: @usda_nifa #NIFAimpacts.

#

Indiana Bar Foundation celebrates 65th anniversary

0

Marilyn Odendahl for www.theindianalawyer.com

During his third year of law school, Clayton Miller was tossed a financial lifeline.

At Indiana University Maurer School of Law, he had been relying on federal student loans and money borrowed from his parents to cover the cost of tuition and living expenses. He was not in danger of having to discontinue his studies, but he was adding to his debt load and increasing the amount of time he needed to repay it.

But then Miller received a $1,000 scholarship from the Indiana Bar Foundation. He refers to the financial aid as a “happy surprise” and said it provided an affirmation of his work in student organizations.

Miller, now a partner at Bamberger Foreman Oswald & Hahn LLP, is an example of the work of the bar foundation. The organization, started in 1950, has grown over the years but its mission has always been the same – promoting civic education and improving access to justice.

Chuck Dunlap has seen this work in his 14 years as executive director.

“One of the things I’m most proud of is the bar foundation, which has had challenges, has the ability to be creative and entrepreneurial in programming and getting resources for the programs that help people,” he said. “Ultimately, the programs draw their strength from the people who volunteer for the bar foundation.”

For several decades, the foundation functioned as a grant-giving organization. It provided funding to support the programs and agencies which aligned with its mission. By the mid-1990s, the foundation began taking a more hands-on role.

In particular, the nonprofit administers the Interest on Lawyer Trust Account program which provides the funds to support the 12 pro bono districts in Indiana. The districts then recruit volunteer attorneys to provide legal representation to indigent Hoosiers. In 2014, a total of 1,300 attorneys and volunteers helped with 2,954 pro bono cases.

In recent years, the foundation stepped in to handle the education programs We the People and the Indiana High School Mock Trial. It provides materials and teacher training, coordinates the competitions, and recruits legal professionals to help with the state competitions.

As the foundation elevated its role in these activities, then-board member Robert Beasley remembered feeling a little bit of trepidation. Certainly the hands-on approach fit with the organization’s mission, but he still worried because the foundation at that time had no track record of being directly involved in programming.

The Muncie attorney, of counsel at Dennis Wenger & Abrell P.C., now holds special appreciation for the foundation staff and board after watching them embrace the new level of activity. He is also “extremely proud” of how supportive the attorneys have been in donating their time.

‘To form a more perfect union’

Miller has volunteered to judge students at the We the People competition and to help train teachers on the material. He especially liked working with the educators.

“I am a great believer in and proponent of the value of civic education,” Miller said, who received the William Oliver Baker Award for his volunteer work at the foundation. “I think that is one of the most important activities done by the foundation.”

One of the many educators who teach the We the People and mock trial curriculum is Janet Chandler, social studies department chair at Hamilton Southeastern High School. She enhanced her own knowledge of the Constitution and the law by receiving a J.D. from Indiana University Robert H. McKinney School of Law in 2011.

Some of her students study the We the People program as part of their regular coursework and meet on Sunday afternoons, doing a tremendous amount of research to learn about the philosophy behind the U.S. system of government. Mock trial participants are selected by audition and then meet often in the evenings to hone their courtroom skills.

Daniel Thomas, attorney in the Marion County Public Defender Agency, is a former student of Chandler who returns occasionally to help the mock trial teams. He teaches them things such as how to make cohesive and cogent objections.

His own experience in mock trial in 2005 and 2006 solidified his desire to become a lawyer. He learned public speaking, critical thinking and even some rules of evidence which helped him during his studies at Valparaiso University Law School.

More than teaching students about the law, Chandler said the programs also present the opportunity for students to interact with adults in the community and learn valuable skills.

“No matter what kind of job they get in the future, they’re going to be able to take the experience they learned and use it in many different professions,” Chandler said.

Munster High School’s We the People alumnus Katherine Ntiamoah is the deputy press attaché and assistant spokesperson for the U.S. Mission to the European Union in Brussels.

She credits her participation in the program with enabling her to delve into the history and the workings of the U.S. government as well as teaching her the importance of civic engagement and public service.

As a student, she went to the national We the People competition in Washington, D.C. She was inspired by the city.

“Every time I go back to D.C., I still have the same feeling that I had more than 10 years ago as a We the People student,” she said.

Providing representation

Talking about his pro bono activities, solo practitioner Casey Cloyd stressed he did nothing special.

“I’m not unique. There are plenty of lawyers that do this,” he said.

Cloyd was referring to his work with the Indiana Appellate Pro Bono Project, a program that helps low-income Hoosiers find an attorney who will volunteer to represent them in an appeal. He considers volunteering a professional obligation and doing appellate work, whether pro bono or not, is something he always enjoys.

Most recently, he represented two women who were trying to retain custody of a little girl who they had been raising since infancy. He received the email alert from the Indiana Court of Appeals as he was driving, so he pulled over to read the eight-page opinion, then called his clients with good news.

“When you help people, whether you get paid or not, it should be something that makes you feel good,” Cloyd said.

To encourage more private dollars for civil legal aid, Dunlap and others spent the spring meeting with community philanthropic groups around the state. The goal was to raise awareness of the need for such services and explain how legal help can prevent bad situations from becoming worse.

In 2016, the foundation will coordinate a conference in Washington, D.C., with other civil legal aid programs that have similarly reached out to private donors. Dunlap said the objective is to provide tools that the legal community can use to create a broader base of philanthropic support.

National reputation

The foundation’s reputation in civic education has drawn national attention. The Center for Civic Education, which runs the We the People program, has tapped the Indiana organization to run the national high school competition.

“It’s a vote of confidence for us as an organization and the network of people around the state who have been doing this for so long and so well,” Dunlap said.

Beyond the classroom, the foundation is working to encourage civic involvement. Former Indiana Chief Justice Randall Shepard is part of that effort. He joined former Congressman Lee Hamilton to present the results of the 2015 Indiana Civic Health Index to several groups around the state.

Shepard sees the index as encouraging individuals and organizations to think about ways they might foster more civic engagement in their communities. He also noted the role the foundation and attorneys have in promoting such involvement.

“I think it’s great for us as a profession that it’s lawyers who work to improve the general public understanding about the rule of law and civic engagement,” he said. “I think lawyers are entitled to take some pride in that.”•

Click here to read more about the benefit dinner’s keynot speaker, journalist Bob Woodward.

VANDERBURGH COUNTY FELONY CHARGES

0
SPONSORED BY DEFENSE ATTORNEY IVAN ARNAEZ.
 DON’T GO TO COURT ALONE. CALL IVAN ARNAEZ @ 812-424-6671.

 Below is a list of felony cases that were filed by the Vanderburgh County Prosecutor’s Office on Thursday, Oct. 8, 2015.

Isaac Lamont Pope Domestic battery, Level 6 felony

Eric Todd Weyer Operating a motor vehicle after forfeiture of license for life, Level 5 felony

Brian Lee Fentress Operating a motor vehicle after forfeiture of license for life, Level 5 felony

Jacob Hayes Armstrong Operating a vehicle with an ACE of .15 or more

Andrew Ryan Peterson Unlawful possession of a syringe, Level 6 felony

Possession of a narcotic drug, Level 6 felony

MIGRATION AND WALLS

0

UE Men’s Soccer Hosts Bradley on Saturday

0

Senior Mark Anthony Gonzalez is one goal away from 25 in his UE career

 After playing back to back matches on the road, the University of Evansville men’s soccer team (2-8, 0-2 MVC) is back at home to host Bradley University (4-7, 1-0 MVC) on Saturday, Oct. 10. The match will be held at Arad McCutchan Stadium and begin at 2:00 p.m. CDT.

 

HOW TO FOLLOW ALONG:

AUDIO – WUEV 91.5 FM

https://www.evansville.edu/wuev/downloads/WUEV_HIGH.m3u

 

LIVE STATS – Stat Broadcast

http://www.statbroadcast.com/events/statmonitr.php?gid=evan

 

WHAT TO KNOW

  • Senior forward Mark Anthony Gonzalez is one goal shy of his 25thcareer goal
  • This is the 800thmatch in program history (425-311-63)
  • The Purple Aces are home for the first time since Sept. 29
  • UE is looking to end a season-high five game losing streak
  • After the conclusion of the men’s soccer match, the Evansville women’s soccer team will take the field, hold their Senior Day festivities and host Drake at 6:00 p.m.

 

THE OPPONENT:

Bradley began the season by winning three of their first four matches, but most recently, have lost six of their last seven. The Braves were also defeated in their last contest 1-0 at Western Illinois (Oct. 5) but did win their MVC opener against Loyola 1-0 (Sept. 25). BU has tallied only eight goals this season, three of which have been scored by freshman forward Frank Bak. Senior forward Grant Bell boasts half of the team’s eight assists. Junior goalkeeper Logan Ketterer has played all 1010 minutes in net for the Braves, amassing 50 saves and posting a 1.52 goals against average.

 

HISTORY

Bradley holds the 15-9-1 lead in the all-time series with the Purple Aces. UE is 4-7-1 in matches played at Arad McCutchan Stadium. Evansville’s last home win over Bradley was a 2-1 victory (Nov. 7, 2009).

 

UE Women’s Soccer Holding Senior Day, Hosting Drake on Saturday

0

The Aces will honor six seniors in a pregame ceremony at Arad McCutchan Stadium

 

EVANSVILLE, Ind. - The University of Evansville women’s soccer team (2-8-2, 0-1-1 Missouri Valley Conference) will hold their 2015 Senior Day on Saturday, Oct. 10 when the Purple Aces host Drake University (5-8, 2-0 MVC). The match will be held at Arad McCutchan Stadium and start at 6:00 p.m. CDT.

 

HOW TO FOLLOW ALONG:

AUDIO – WUEV 91.5 FM

https://www.evansville.edu/wuev/downloads/WUEV_HIGH.m3u

 

LIVE STATS – Stat Broadcast

http://www.statbroadcast.com/events/statmonitr.php?gid=evan

 

WHAT TO KNOW

  • UE will honor six student athletes and one senior athletic training student as part of 2015 Senior Day festivities
  • The Aces eye their first win in MVC play this season
  • Evansville is looking for their first win since Sept. 13
  • The all-time series with Drake is tied 9-9
  • Saturday will be a soccer doubleheader at McCutchan Stadium with the men’s team playing Bradley at 2:00 p.m. CDT and the women’s soccer match to follow

 

SENIOR DAY

Evansville will be holding a Senior Day ceremony prior to Saturday’s match. The Aces will honor six student athletes and one athletic training student. The six senior student athletes are midfielder Allie Arguello, goalkeeper Simone Busby, midfielder Caitie Dierkes, forward Holyn Marshall, forward Kayla Smith, and defender Abby Springer.

 

ALLIE ARGUELLO – SR, M

MVC Commissioner’s Academic Excellence Award (2013-’14, ‘14-’15)…MVC Honor Roll (2012-’13, ‘13-’14, ‘14-’15)…Tied for team-lead in assists (2)…Scored first career goal vs. UT-Martin (Aug. 23).

 

BRONWYN BOSWELL – JR, M

MVC Offensive Player of the Week with two goal performance vs. IUPUI (Sept. 15)…All-MVC Preseason Team (‘15), NSCAA All-Great Lakes Region Second Team (‘14), MVC First Team (‘14), MVC All-Freshman Team  (‘13).

 

SIMONE BUSBY – SR, GK

MVC Commissioner’s Academic Excellence Award (2013-’14, ‘14-’15)…MVC Honor Roll (2012-’13, ‘13-’14, ‘14-’15)…All-MVC Preseason Team (‘15), NSCAA All-Great Lakes Region Third Team (‘14), MVC Goalkeeper of the Year (‘12,’14), MVC First Team (‘12,’14)…Holds single season (nine) and career (22) record for solo shutouts at UE.

 

CAITIE DIERKES – SR, M

MVC Commissioner’s Academic Excellence Award (2013-’14, ‘14-’15) …MVC Honor Roll (2012-’13, ‘13-’14, ‘14-’15)…Scored first career goal at Vanderbilt (Sept. 20).

 

HOLYN MARSHALL – SR, F

MVC Commissioner’s Academic Excellence Award (2013-’14) …MVC Honor Roll (2012-’13, ‘13-’14, ‘14-’15)…All three of her career goals were scored in 2014…Played defense each of her first three seasons with UE.

 

KAYLA SMITH – SR, F

MVC Commissioner’s Academic Excellence Award (2013-’14, ‘14-’15)…MVC Honor Roll (2012-’13, ‘13-’14, ‘14-’15) …MVC All-Freshman Team (‘12)…Appeared in 20 matches last season, making 13 starts…Scored four points on two goals and two assists…Boasts 10 goals, seven assists and 27 points in her UE career.

 

ABBY SPRINGER – SR, D/M

MVC Commissioner’s Academic Excellence Award (2013-’14, ‘14-’15) …MVC Honor Roll (2013-’14, ‘14-’15)…MVC Freshman of the Year (‘12) and MVC All-Freshman Team (‘12).

 

 

THE OPPONENT

Drake enters this weekend in first place in the MVC, having already posted victories over Illinois State and Indiana State. Most recently, the Bulldogs were defeated 3-0 at Oklahoma State on Wednesday night. Junior midfielder Rebecca Rodgers has a team-high five goals, three assists and 15 points this season. Freshman midfielder Alyssa Brand also has five goals as junior midfielder Kayla Armstrong has provided an additional three assists. Junior goalkeeper Brooke Dennis has a team-low 1.78 goals against average and has logged 62 saves this season.

 

THE COACHES

Evansville is led by eighth year head coach Krista McKendree, a four year standout with the Purple Aces and the only All-American in UE women’s soccer history.

 

Drake’s head coach is Lindsay Horner in her eighth season.

 

HISTORY

The Bulldogs and Purple Aces have split the all-time series 9-9. The Purple Aces are 5-3 in matches played in Evansville.

 

Last 5 meetings:

Date Location UE Opponent Result
Nov. 7, 2014 ^ Normal, Ill. 2 0 W
Sept. 28, 2014 Des Moines, Iowa 1 0 W
Sept. 29, 2013 Evansville, Ind. 1 0 W
Oct. 7, 2012 Des Moines, Iowa 0 1 L
Oct. 30, 2011 ^ Evansville, Ind. 1 0 W

 

^ = MVC Tournament

 

LAST MEETING

Evansville eliminated Drake from the 2014 MVC Tournament with a 2-0 victory in the Semifinals (Nov. 7, 2014). Evansville’s Bronwyn Boswell and Montana Portenier both scored in the victory. Simone Busby also notched her ninth solo shutout of the season and program record setting 13th shutout of the year in the win.

 

LAST HOME MEETING

UE won the last home meeting 1-0 against Drake (Sept. 29, 2013) on the first career goal from defender Emily Richardson.

 

LAST TIME OUT

The Aces were defeated 1-0 at UNI last Saturday (Oct. 3). The lone score was an 82nd minute goal. UE senior forward Kayla Smith had a team-high five shots. Evansville also received their first yellow card of the season.

 

LEADING OFF

Junior forward Bronwyn Boswell leads the Purple Aces with three goals, two assists, eight points, 35 shots, 14 shots on goal and one game winning goal this season. Senior midfielder Allie Arguello, and freshman midfielder Molly Lear also have a team-best two assists each. Senior goalkeeper Simone Busby has the lowest GAA (0.95), 32 saves and highest saves percentage (.780) on the Aces this season.

 

FOR THREE!

The UE women’s soccer team has two shutouts this season and is looking for their third shutout of the year when the team plays Drake. The Aces have seven shutouts in the 18 meetings with Drake including six in the final seven contests.

 

IN THE CLASSROOM

UE women’s soccer received an NSCAA College Team Academic Award (Sept. 23) for their 3.47 GPA in the 2014-15 academic year. This is their ninth straight year receiving the honor and 11th overall.

 

WHAT AN HONOR

Boswell was named MVC Offensive Player of the Week (Sept. 15) for her two goal game vs. IUPUI. This is the first Player of the Week honor in her collegiate career.

 

TALE OF TWO HALVES

Evansville is outscoring their opponents 7-6 in the first half but being outpaced 11-3 after halftime.

 

GOOD BEHAVIOR

The Purple Aces have only received one yellow card and no red cards this season.

 

WE’RE NUMBER ONE

The UE women’s soccer team was ranked #1 in the 2015 Missouri Valley Conference preseason coach’s poll. The Aces will look to unseat back to back champion Illinois State for the title this year. Boswell, Busby, and sophomore forward Montana Portenier were named to the preseason All-Conference team. Sophomore midfielder/forward Nicki Baham received honorable mention.

 

NATIONAL HONOR

Busby missed the team’s first two games competing for the Guyana National Team in CONCACAF Qualifying. They won 8-0 over St. Kitts and Nevis and then tied Cuba 1-1. Guyana advanced to the next round over Cuba on goal differential.

 

UP FOR THE CHALLENGE

Evansville will play three teams that completed last season in the RPI Top 100. Those opponents are Illinois State (32), Miami (Ohio) (58), and Vanderbilt (96).

 

HOSTING THE CHAMPIONSHIP

Evansville is hosting the 2015 MVC Women’s Soccer Championship this year. The semifinals will take place on Fri., Nov. 6 with the Championship match to take place on Sun., Nov. 8. All matches will be held at Arad McCutchan Stadium in Evansville, Ind.

 

Life Chain is Sunday, October 11

0

On Sunday afternoon, October 11, at 1:30 p.m., Right to Life of Southwest Indiana will host the annual Life Chain.  Life Chain is a silent prayer vigil to protect life and oppose abortion.  In this our 28th year of public witness on behalf of rejected PrebornChildren; Life Chain will again fill sidewalks in over 1,500 cities and towns in the U.S. and Canada. It is an opportunity for people to unite in prayer and to stand up for the rights of the unborn. They will stand in honor of the more than57 million children whose lives have been lost to abortion in our country since 1973.  Every year young women report choosing life for their unborn children over abortion after reading the signs and seeing the people praying at the Life Chain.

Supporters will line Green River Road sidewalks beginning at the Lloyd Expressway and going south.  The Life Chain supporters will gather at Brinker’s Jewelers parking lot at the corner of Green River and the Lloyd Expressway for free refreshments and to pick up signs.  Free signs will be distributed beginning at 1:30 p.m. Supporters will line the street from 2 p.m. to 3 p.m.

According to Mary Ellen Van Dyke, Executive Director of Right to Life of Southwest Indiana, “Supporters of unborn babies and their moms will stand together respectfully and prayerfully to honor the sanctity of life. This year with all the attacks against the sanctity of human life, conscience and religious freedom and the federal funding for abortions in Obamacare, many prayers are needed.”

Supporters of Life will hold signs that say:

  • ABORTION KILLS CHILDREN 
  • JESUS FORGIVES AND HEALS 
  • ADOPTION: THE LOVING OPTION 
  • LORD, FORGIVE US AND OUR NATION 
  • ABORTION HURTS WOMEN 
  • PRAY TO END ABORTION 
  • LIFE—THE FIRST INALIENABLE RIGHT
  • DEFUND PLANNED PARENTHOOD

The Life Chain follows a strict Code of Conduct, is peaceful, and urges all family members, young and old, to attend.  Everyone who believes in the protection of unborn children and their mothers is invited to participate.  The event will be safe, peaceful and legal.  You may bring chairs and strollers.  All ages are welcome and the Life Chain will be held, come rain or shine.

Right to Life of Southwest Indiana with 50,000 supporters protects life.  We exist to protect the right to life of innocent human life from fertilization to natural death.

Deed allows owners to make wells deeper, court rules

0

Jennifer Nelson for www.theindianalawyer.com

A family that sold mineral rights to a company but reserved the rights to oil and gas from certain producing wells was not restricted by the deed from making the reserved wells deeper, the Indiana Court of Appeals held Friday.

The judges affirmed summary judgment in favor of the Mumford family on Allen Gray Limited Partnership IV’s motion for summary judgment. Mumford reserved oil and gas rights for 20 years from the date of the conveyance and for “as long thereafter as oil and gas is being produced” from the property. The deed provided that after the 20-year period expired, the Mumfords’ reservation would continue as to each well then producing and as to “the drilling unit upon which each such producing well is located as evidenced by the drilling permit” until production ceases and the well is plugged.

Allen Gray argued that the reference to the drilling permit limited the family’s reservation to oil and gas that could be produced under the terms of permits that existed at the end of the 20-year term but could not deepen existing wells because that would require a new permit.

The trial court denied its motion for summary judgment and ruled in favor of the Mumfords, finding that the reservation included the acreage surrounding each well as defined by the permit.

“(The deed) explicitly reserves for Mumford ‘the drilling unit upon which’ each producing well is located, and says nothing about the depth of the well or any other aspect of the permit other than the ‘drilling unit.’ Mumford reserved the acreage on which the wells were drilled, and that reservation of the drilling unit does not limit Mumford’s ability to deepen the wells on those units if it can obtain a permit to do that,” Judge Melissa May wrote in Allen Gray Limited Partnership IV v. Bishop Mumford, Christopher Mumford, Elizabeth B. Mumford, Richardson S. Mumford, Thomas F. Mumford, Jr., and William M. Mumford, 26A01-1503-MI-92.

“The trial court correctly determined the reservation applied to the surface area of the ‘drilling unit,’ and did not restrict Mumford from making the reserved wells deeper. Summary judgment for Mumford therefore was not error, and we affirm.”