On June 16, 2025, Evansville Police Department (EPD) Lieutenant Stacy L. Shirley and Sergeant William (Bill) C. Shirley were each charged with Corrupt Business Influence (Racketeering), Official Misconduct and multiple counts of Fraud. The investigation began in May 2025 after concerns were raised regarding the Shirleys’ off-duty employment with the Evansville Housing Authority (EHA). Bill and Stacy were placed on administrative leave during the investigation.

It was determined that both Bill and Stacy were employed by the EHA to perform off-duty security. Bill was responsible for scheduling officers for off-duty with the EHA. The investigation found that Bill regularly reported hours he did not work. This included hours he reported while he was on duty for EPD. Stacy also reported hours she had not worked. These discrepancies were corroborated through GPS and cell phone data.

A separate investigation was also conducted into the Shirleys’ off-duty employment with Dillard’s retail store. Evidence showed that Bill frequently clocked Stacy in for shifts while she was already on duty at EPD.

These actions were verified through pay records and in-store surveillance footage. As a result of this investigation, it was also learned that Stacy regularly failed to work her full scheduled shifts for EPD. Stacy did not use paid time off to account for her absences. Due to the findings in this investigation, Bill and Stacy’s leave status has been changed to unpaid administrative leave and charges were submitted to the Vanderburgh County Prosecutor’s office. An arrest warrant was issued and Bill and Stacy were

given the opportunity to turn themselves in. Their employment with the Evansville Police Department will be determined by the Police Merit Commission.

Arrest Made For Hit-And-Run Related To Shooting Investigation Alexis M Wilhite (21) has been arrested and charged with leaving the scene of an accident with injury and driving with license suspended with injury. While fleeing the shooting scene described below, Wilhite struck the victim with her vehicle, causing serious bodily injury. Wilhite did not report the accident or attempt to aid the victim.

The shooting investigation is on-going at this time.

One Deceased After Shooting Leaves Multiple Injured

On 6/15/2025 officers were dispatched to the 300 block of Taylor Ave in reference to a Shots Fired run.

Multiple 911 calls were received stating several shots were fired and there was more than one victim. Officers on scene learned a large party was hosted at the location. As everyone was leaving the party,

shots were fired outside of the venue. Multiple people were injured by gunfire and at least one person was struck by a vehicle. One of the victims who was shot did not survive their injuries. Investigators on scene spoke with several witnesses. Witnesses stated the party ended and as everyone was leaving, shots were fired outside. It was also learned that there was more than one person shooting.

Detectives spoke with residents near the scene and searched the area for any cameras that might have captured the incident. The identity of the deceased will be released by the Vanderburgh County Coroner’s Office. The investigation is ongoing and anyone with information is asked to contact the Adult Investigation Unit at 812-436-7979.

News Release

6/16/2025

Narcotics Investigation Leads To Methamphetamine Dealing Arrest

On 6/13/2025 the Evansville-Vanderburgh County Drug Task Force (EVCDTF) conducted an investigation into a large amount of methamphetamine being delivered to an address. EVCDTF detectives began surveillance on the address. Davont M Terry (27) was observed in the area multiple times before approaching the address and picking up the package containing methamphetamine. A traffic stop was conducted where Terry was taken into custody and charged with Dealing in Methamphetamine. Six pounds of suspected methamphetamine were seized.

On 6/16/2025 Officer Staats was dispatched to a residence in reference to a medical emergency. The caller stated there was a male at this location who was “blue in color, not responding, not breathing”. Central dispatch then began giving the caller CPR instructions. The caller was not comfortable providing CPR.

Officer Staats arrived and entered the residence. When Officer Staats located the male subject, he immediately began giving chest compressions. While treating the male, Officer Staats communicated calmly with a female in the home. The male began breathing on his own as Evansville Fire Department (EFD) arrived.

Officer Staats then turned over care of the male to EFD.

Officer Staats showed great control in a chaotic situation. He was able to communicate clearly and effectively with the female inside the home. His calm focus allowed him to provide appropriate care to the male and comfort the female. Officer Staats is commended for his courage and professionalism