Could a New Stadium be in the Works Downtown?

0
By Joe Wallace – January 30, 2025
Indiana House Bill 1451 (HB 1451), introduced on January 21, 2025, proposes increasing the maximum amount of covered taxes captured within the Evansville Professional Sports and Convention Development Area (PSCDA). The bill aims to raise the current cap of $10 per resident to a flat $5 million annually, providing Evansville with greater financial resources to fund development projects related to professional sports and conventions. In fiscal year 2024, the PSCDA captured approximately $680,000 in revenue, and this proposed increase could significantly boost the city’s development capacity.

While the bill does not explicitly earmark funds for a semi-professional baseball stadium, the additional revenue could potentially support such a project, depending on decisions made by local leaders. The project appears to align with ongoing discussions about enhancing sports infrastructure in Evansville.

The idea of a baseball stadium has a contentious history in Evansville politics. In the 2003 mayoral election, Democratic candidate Jonathan Weinzapfel successfully campaigned against incumbent Republican Mayor Russell Lloyd Jr., partly by mocking Lloyd’s proposal for a $20 million downtown baseball stadium. Lloyd envisioned the stadium as the home of a AAA baseball team affiliated with the Los Angeles Dodgers, a move he believed would bring economic benefits and revitalization to the downtown area.

Weinzapfel seized on this proposal as a symbol of fiscal irresponsibility. One of the most memorable moments of his campaign was a television ad that featured a court jester stumbling around the bases to the tune of “Take Me Out to the Ball Game.” The ad ridiculed the stadium plan as extravagant and unnecessary, framing it as a self-indulgent project by Lloyd. The commercial struck a chord with voters, and the image of Lloyd as a “fiscal jester” stuck with him for the rest of his political career. Weinzapfel’s campaign emphasized prudent financial management and practical investments in the community, which resonated with voters and helped him secure victory.

As of now, it is unclear which specific entity in Evansville is driving the push for a state grant to fund a semi-professional baseball stadium under the provisions of HB 1451. Typically, such efforts involve collaboration between local government, economic development organizations, and private sector stakeholders. Given the historical debates over similar projects, any proposal for a stadium is likely to attract significant public and political scrutiny.

In summary, HB 1451 could provide Evansville with substantial new funding opportunities through the PSCDA, potentially enabling projects like a semi-professional baseball stadium. However, the city’s history with stadium proposals—particularly the 2003 campaign where Weinzapfel’s ad lampooned Lloyd’s $20 million baseball stadium plan—shows how divisive such initiatives can be. The success of any current effort will likely depend on how it is framed to the public and whether it avoids the perception of fiscal irresponsibility that doomed previous proposals.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here