The Evansville City Council’s unanimous decision to establish a Designated Outdoor Refreshment Area (DORA) aims to invigorate the downtown area by permitting patrons to carry alcoholic beverages from participating establishments within a specified zone. As the city prepares to launch this initiative in April, with 22 restaurants and bars on board, it’s essential to consider the potential impacts on economic growth, crime rates, and livability, especially given the concerns of downtown’s predominantly older residents.
Economic Growth
Implementing a DORA can bolster the economic vitality of downtown areas. By allowing patrons to move freely with beverages, these zones can enhance the appeal of downtown districts, potentially increasing foot traffic and benefiting local businesses. For instance, a report from Ohio State University noted that DORAs could support the economic vitality of downtown areas, especially as they recover from the pandemic.
However, the success of a DORA in stimulating economic growth depends on various factors, including effective management, community engagement, and the unique characteristics of the area. It’s crucial to set realistic expectations and recognize that while a DORA can contribute to economic development, it is not a standalone solution. It will also create a need to hire more law enforcement officers to keep downtown Evansville from being a stomping ground for wandering drunks.
Crime and Safety
Concerns about increased crime, such as fistfights and robberies, in areas with relaxed open container laws are valid. However, evidence suggests that with proper planning and enforcement, DORAs do not necessarily lead to higher crime rates. For example, in Montgomery, Ohio, the police department conducts routine patrols and enforces responsible behavior within the DORA, ensuring that the boundaries are strictly maintained and that alcoholic beverages are not carried outside the designated area.
The key to maintaining safety is proactive management, including clear signage, designated patrols, and community involvement. By establishing and enforcing guidelines, Evansville can mitigate potential safety concerns associated with the DORA.
Livability and Community Impact
The introduction of a DORA can have mixed effects on livability, particularly in areas with a significant residential population. In Jasper, Indiana, discussions about implementing a DORA raised questions about its impact on downtown residents and future development.
For Evansville, where the downtown population is relatively small and has experienced slow growth, it’s essential to balance the interests of businesses and residents. Engaging with the community, particularly older residents, to address concerns such as noise, litter, and safety will be crucial. Implementing measures like restricted hours, designated consumption areas, and regular clean-up efforts can help maintain the quality of life for downtown inhabitants.
Conclusion
As Evansville moves forward with establishing its DORA, the city can look to the experiences of other communities to anticipate potential outcomes. While DORAs offer opportunities for economic enhancement and increased vibrancy, they also require careful planning and management to address concerns related to crime and livability. By proactively engaging with residents, enforcing regulations, and fostering collaboration between businesses and law enforcement, Evansville can work towards creating a DORA that benefits the downtown residential community.
FOOTNOTE: This article was posted by the CCO without bias, opinion, or editing.
Alcohol in outdoor public areas is asking for trouble.