| 1818 |
John B. Stinson |
| August 24, 1818 |
Hazael Putnam |
| 1822 |
Alanson Warner |
| 1824 |
James Newman |
| February 1827 |
Alanson Warner |
| September 1827 |
Daniel Miller |
| 1831 |
Levi Price |
| 1834 |
Edward Hopkins |
| 1835 |
Daniel Miller |
| 1839 |
Thomas F. Stockwell |
| 1843 |
William W. Walker |
| 1847 |
John Echols |
| 1849 |
John S. Terry |
| 1853 |
John S. Gavitt |
| 1857 |
John B. Hall |
| 1859 |
John S. Gavitt |
| May 1862 |
Joseph B. Cox |
| 1863 |
George Wolflin |
| August 1865 |
Robert Early |
| October 1865 |
Alex Darling |
| 1867 |
Jacob H. Miller |
| 1870 |
Adolph Pfafflin |
| 1874 |
Christ Wunderlich |
| 1878 |
J.A. Lemcke |
| 1880 |
Thomas Kerth |
| 1884 |
Charles Schaum |
| 1888 |
Frank Pritchett |
| 1892 |
Andrew Richardt |
| 1894 |
Charles G. Covert |
| 1899 |
Martin Koepke |
| 1902 |
Christian W. Kratz |
| 1907 |
William E. Barnes |
| 1911 |
John J. Davis |
| 1915 |
William Habbe |
| 1919 |
Herbert Males |
| 1923 |
Fred Henke |
| 1924 |
Shelby McDowell |
| 1929 |
William Ruston |
| 1931 |
William Habbe |
| 1933 |
Clyde M. Hesmer |
| 1937 |
Edwin Diekmann |
| 1941 |
Val Dietsch |
| 1943 |
Bert Martin |
| 1945 |
Arval Barr |
| 1947 |
Bert Martin |
| 1949 |
Frank McDonald |
| 1959 |
Greshim Grim |
| 1967 |
Jerry E. Riney |
| 1975 |
James A. Degroote |
| 1983 |
Clarence Shepard |
| 1991 |
Ray Hamner |
| 1999 |
Brad Ellsworth |
| 2007 |
Eric Williams |
| May 2014-Current |
Dave Wedding |
